[TYPO3-v4] CardLayout glitches

[Kay Strobach]

Hi Tolleiv,

Could you please send me you skype username (via personal mail), so that
i can collect a complete list of problems, and how to reproduce them -
it seems that you spent a lot of time in research ;)

I have some freetime now, so that i can take a deeper look.

The first submitted patch contained no autocreation of cards, so that
only new and explizitly extjsed modules got a card (to be 100%
compatible, but i was forced to make a card for every module :( )

Regards
Kay

Am 24.09.2011 20:48, schrieb Tolleiv Nietsch:
> 
> @Kay - well even if you haven't see it yet it's quite easy to describe
> the crash case. Whenever you try to integrate old and new modules and
> whenever you want to provide the possibility to jump back into a "ExtJS"
> modules you need that feature and if the Core provides the API for the
> returnUrl we've to make sure that it works always and that modules that
> rely on that feature keep working.
> 
> In my perception the current implementation of the CardLayout breaks
> backend usability - in some cases it even breaks functionality. Since
> obviously nobody is able to provide solutions at the moment  I'd vote to
> remove it from the 4.6 feature-list and rollback the changes made so far.
> 
> Any further opinions?
> 
> Cheers,
> Tolleiv
> 
> 
> 
> Kay Strobach schrieb:
>> Hi Tolleiv,
>>
>>> If you read the notes and comments of the patch, you'll also see that
>>> the "problem" that some cards might not provide a URL and that therefore
>>> navigation supported by the $returnUrl parameter will never work with
>>> the CardLayout - this is imho a significant usability drawback.
>>
>> Most of the extjs modules i've seen do not use classic modules where a
>> return uri is usefull at all.
>> They use extjs windows and other methods to provide the same behaviour
>> ;) - most users won't see any difference ;)
>> #
>> Regards
>> Kay
>>
>>
> 


-- 
http://www.kay-strobach.de - Open Source Rocks

TYPO3 .... inspiring people to share!
Get involved: http://typo3.org

Answere was usefull: https://flattr.com/profile/kaystrobach