[TYPO3-v4] CardLayout glitches

[Tolleiv Nietsch]

@Kay - well even if you haven't see it yet it's quite easy to describe 
the crash case. Whenever you try to integrate old and new modules and 
whenever you want to provide the possibility to jump back into a "ExtJS" 
modules you need that feature and if the Core provides the API for the 
returnUrl we've to make sure that it works always and that modules that 
rely on that feature keep working.

In my perception the current implementation of the CardLayout breaks 
backend usability - in some cases it even breaks functionality. Since 
obviously nobody is able to provide solutions at the moment  I'd vote to 
remove it from the 4.6 feature-list and rollback the changes made so far.

Any further opinions?

Cheers,
Tolleiv



Kay Strobach schrieb:
> Hi Tolleiv,
>
>> If you read the notes and comments of the patch, you'll also see that
>> the "problem" that some cards might not provide a URL and that therefore
>> navigation supported by the $returnUrl parameter will never work with
>> the CardLayout - this is imho a significant usability drawback.
>
> Most of the extjs modules i've seen do not use classic modules where a
> return uri is usefull at all.
> They use extjs windows and other methods to provide the same behaviour
> ;) - most users won't see any difference ;)
> #
> Regards
> Kay
>
>

-- 
twitter.com/tolleiv
blog.tolleiv.de - www.aoemedia.de