[TYPO3-english] Shortcut with 301 option for shortlinks

[d.ros]

Hi Bernd,

i´ll answer inline:

 > you have a page www.domain.com/short with content,
 > then you move the content to www.domain.com/in/a/deeper/tree
 > then you change the first page into a shortcut of the second page
 >
 > now you want all links to the first page to redirect with 301 to the
 > second page?


NO: I have content in www.domain.com/in/a/deeper/tree and for some 
marketing reasons I want to have a short link to that deeplink. And this 
should be adjustable/maintainalbe by an editor, as this can be a common 
usecase in larger pages. And this should not disturb any SEO things or 
produce double content.


 >
 > as I mentioned before:
 > all links inside of typo3 will never point to www.domain.com/short but
 > only to www.domain.com/in/a/deeper/tree.
 >
 > 'deeplinks' from external may call the old URL and will be redirected
 > (without 301) to the new page.
 > BUT with realURL you can insert a 301 redirect by yourself. I don't know
 > whether collUrl has the same options.



That this can be set within realUrl and coolUri is a clear case but it´s 
some kindo nogo option for an editor.



Got the point ?



Cheers

David






Am 29.07.2013 17:02, schrieb bernd wilke:
> Am 29.07.13 16:19, schrieb d.ros:
>> Am 29.07.2013 16:05, schrieb bernd wilke:
>>> Am 29.07.13 12:33, schrieb d.ros:
>>>> Hello,
>>>>
>>>> once there was #17037 to make shortcut handling better. But this still
>>>> has a litte space to work even more better which could be resolved with
>>>> an additional switch where the name could be "chosen page with 301".
>>>>
>>>> At the moment the link points directly to the target page, but there
>>>> are
>>>> usecases where it makes sense to give an editor the possiblity to
>>>> generate shortcut links pointing to pages which reside deeper in a
>>>> page.
>>>>
>>>> Atm. you could make a new page and use "show content from" which has
>>>> the
>>>> disadvantage of double content. There are also possiblities to set
>>>> those
>>>> entries with realURL or cooluri or even .htaccess but this is quite
>>>> unhandy for editors.
>>>>
>>>> If you could set an 301 option to the shortcut, you would have a link
>>>> like www.domain.com/short redirecting to
>>>> www.domain.com/in/a/deeper/tree
>>>> with a 301
>>>>
>>>> IMHO it makes quite sense to make this setting settable for editors.
>>>
>>> As of TYPO3 4.7 (or was it 4.6?) links to pages of type shortcut are
>>> generated as links to the target page.
>>> you only get a redirect if you call the page immediate
>>> (index.php?id=123)
>>>
>>> it's a pity that external URL is not handled in the same way.
>>> I just had a project with static export and had to replace the internal
>>> page url with the corresponding external url.
>>>
>>>
>>> bernd
>>
>> External link is not an option as you cannot generate the short url on
>> the fly. ATM: The only workaroud is to place the shortcut under a tree
>> that is hidden from pagepath, open that page so the url cache ( cooluri
>> or realurl - doesn´t matter ) is filled and switching the page to
>> shortcut mode. That way you can manage shortcut urls as editor. But once
>> the url cache is emptied the links are gone and you have to respawn them
>> by hand.
>>
>> so file a vote for this please !
>
> I don't understand your wish or your problem. (external url was just a
> annotation about the different handling of external URLs)
>
> I try to resume your doing:
>
> you have a page www.domain.com/short with content,
> then you move the content to www.domain.com/in/a/deeper/tree
> then you change the first page into a shortcut of the second page
>
> now you want all links to the first page to redirect with 301 to the
> second page?
>
> as I mentioned before:
> all links inside of typo3 will never point to www.domain.com/short but
> only to www.domain.com/in/a/deeper/tree.
>
> 'deeplinks' from external may call the old URL and will be redirected
> (without 301) to the new page.
> BUT with realURL you can insert a 301 redirect by yourself. I don't know
> whether collUrl has the same options.
>
>
> BTW: which T3-version do you use?
>
> bernd

 >
 >
 > BTW: which T3-version do you use?