[TYPO3-dev] T3ONE.com

[Elmar HInz]

> 
> On another post on this thread, you said that it must be integrated into
> typo3.org before it is "allowed" to exist. This stays in contrary to the
> slogan "don't talk, do it". Imagine: You have this idea of t3one.com and
> want to see what happens if you publish it. What speaks against running
> it on a different server, different URL? IMHO this has nothing to do
> with the URL. (See trac for example: It's running at digital-district.de
> - just because someone set it up once. Of course, trac.typo3.org would
> be easier to remember as
> http://svn.t3.digitaldistrict.de/cgi-bin/trac.cgi but I don't see a big
> problem with this. For me, it's more important to have things (like
> trac) online, so that I can use it, the URL doesn't matter.
>

The important difference is that this Trac only passivlely displays the
central common repository. It is only used to browse the source. It is
not used to edit anything. There is a reason why we don't use the wiki. A
trac with wiki editing would belong below the typo3.org url.
 
> What we can take from your feedback is the following: You would like to
> see it integrated in typo3.org in the meaning of a "single username per
> person" (like the bugtracker where you can log in with your typo3.org
> account). I think it would be way better to request this improvement:
> "Please add single sign-on for t3one.com so that I can log in with my
> existing typo3.org-account". Way better than writing "I don't like
> t3one.com because of XYZ".
> 
> That's the way I understood you.


You did unserstand me partly. 

Yes, typo3.org really needs improvement with community tools. That is
something I tell since 3 years now, but with web2 this vision becomes part
of everybodys mind.

No, I don't think it a nice option to integrate that into typo3.org. I
regard that as an absolute prerequest. I can't judge if this people misuse
the name of the community for personal interests or if it is only the
proceeding that takes the wrong way. I hope for the latter. But the way it
is done now does not look correct for me. It has a smell.

Regards

Elmar