[TYPO3-hci] Position of close and delete button

Helmut Hummel typo3 at jhpc.de
Fri Mar 7 21:18:55 CET 2008


Hi Dmitry,

Dmitry Dulepov [typo3] wrote:
> 
> Helmut Hummel wrote:
>> Normally when working with high resolution screens, users do not use 
>> maximized windows. And if they do so, they are used to move the mouse 
>> in the to right corner to close/minimize the window (at least on 
>> windows systems).
> 
> Well, I started to work with computers in 1990 in text mode (80x25), so 
> I always maximize windows. Next I used Windows 3.0 in 640x480, where 
> full screen was necessary for normal work. But I never used close button 
> on Windows, I always closed window using Alt+F4 or Ctrl+F4. I am on Mac 
> now and I use Command+Q :)

Well, I tend to say, that keybord shortcuts are only used by "power users", not 
by "normal" editors.

> May be I am too serious or too pedantic but my feeling is that people 
> should not be forced to do extra movements if it can be avoided. Most 
> used functions should be easily accessible and should be "under hand". 
> You move your finger and function is done. This is ideal :)

Basicly I agree with you.

> Unfortunately keyboard shortcuts do not work well in browsers. So 
> position of close button becomes esssential. If we can avoid extra mouse 
> movements, it would be a plus :) If not, well, sad but not killing bad.

At least I think the close button should be sperated from the save buttons, as 
Jens suggested. So I'm fine with the close button on the very left (which 
reminds me of Mac Windows, which have the close/minimize/maximize stuff on the left.

> I cannot say I have best solution for the problem. This is why I am 
> asking for opinions :)

Well, you ask, you get ;)

BTW. I also whish you a happy birthday :)

-- 
lib.salutation = TEXT
lib.salutation.value = Kind regards, Helmut
lib.salutation.lang.de = Viele Grüße, Helmut


More information about the TYPO3-team-hci mailing list