[TYPO3-core] Voting for the new release cycles for TYPO3 CMS

[Alexander Stehlik]

Hi guys

I have the feeling that something is strange about the vote:

1. I (think) I voted "yes" but it changed to "no" after some time
2. I can edit the votes of all non registered participants
3. When I remember correctly the "Yes" votes where clearly winning 
(somewhat around 130) but now "No" is winning, the "Yes" votes have been 
reduced in a large amount.

What's going on there?

Kind regards,
Alex

Am 28.07.2014 um 15:57 schrieb Ernesto Baschny:
> bernd wilke schrieb am 28.07.2014 13:33:
>
>>> after a long preparation phase, discussions and refinement, we ask the
>>> whole TYPO3 Community to vote on the new concept for the release cycles
>>> for our TYPO3 CMS product in future.
>>>
>>> Every member of the TYPO3 Community (all active contributors, extension
>>> authors, Association members, team members, mailing list participants,
>>> TYPO3 users etc) is invited to participate.
>>>
>>> Please read (or re-read) the Blueprint:
>>>
>>> http://wiki.typo3.org/Blueprints/Release
>>>
>>> And afterwards give one vote on the matter on this Doodle:
>>>
>>> https://doodle.com/vw5wwxds3b3952yv
>>
>> voting for something in a wiki, which can be changed from everyone
>> everytime?
>>
>> I think a copy transfered to a static version might be more trustworthy.
>
> That's perfectly valid point, but unavoidable. As an example, I just
> fixed minor inconsistencies in the document after the voting started,
> you might have noticed:
>
> http://wiki.typo3.org/wiki/index.php?title=Blueprints%2FRelease&diff=73091&oldid=73088
>
> Gladly you can refer to the specific version in Wiki, and even see the
> history of changes. Which is not possible in case of a "static version",
> which I could alter any time without you even noting. So in my opinion
> the Wiki is much more trustworthy than other means (considering that we
> do not have Admin access to this wiki of course...)
>
> So basically you are agreeing to this:
>
> http://wiki.typo3.org/wiki/index.php?title=Blueprints/Release&oldid=73091
>
> which is "unchangeable".
>
> Cheers,
> Ernesto
>


-- 
Alexander Stehlik
alexander.stehlik at gmail.com