[TYPO3-core] Gridelements in the core?

Tolleiv Nietsch info at tolleiv.de
Wed May 2 08:42:22 CEST 2012


I'd prefer not to move it into the Core with the existing code quality.

 From my point of view both PHP files and JavaScript files carry code in 
a quality which would never be able to pass the review.

Besides that this would also mean that TemplaVoila would conflict with 
the TYPO3 Core - I guess some people might get upset.


Jigal van Hemert schrieb:
> Hi,
> On Twitter a small discussion started with the question "gridelements
> for the core. what's missing?"
> The main question is of whether it should be included in the core at all.
> The general policy is to include the really necessary parts and leave
> the rest to extensions. There are already cases of hardly maintained
> parts which are also not really necessary and which should in fact be
> moved to normal extensions. There is already a forge issue about this.
> Extensions with similar functionality (automaketemplate, templavoila)
> are not part of the core.
> One could argue that it is a bit strange that BE layouts are included in
> the core, and the next logical step -- gridelements -- are not. IMO BE
> layouts was meant to fix the rather limited and rigid four-column
> backend layout with left, normal, right and border. The areas in BE
> layouts are still connected to "colpos" values and can be rendered in
> the frontend with the usual template-marker-system.
> What do you think?

http://twitter.com/tolleiv - http://blog.tolleiv.de

More information about the TYPO3-team-core mailing list