[TYPO3-core] RFC #15681: Duplicate "Navigation title" can break realurl URL decoding

[Christian Kuhn]

Hey,

On 12/22/2010 01:35 PM, JoH asenau wrote:
>>> And if you don't want to use realurl? Should you be forced to use a
>>> unique title?
>>> I have seen sites with three "My ----site" pages each completely
>>> different for different fe_groups. A problem for realurl, but not if
>>> you don't use realurl.
>>>
>>> -1 for unnecessary restrictions...
>>
>> -1 from me as well for the same reasons.
>
> Just to explain it a bit further: IMHO it's the job of realURL (or any other "speaking URL"  extension) to provide these settings and notify the user about the change, so that only users of realURL would have to change their page titles accordingly.

I expected a reaction like this ...

As it will be pretty hard to fight a solution to the core after two -1, 
this issue will be dropped again and moved to ext:real_url. It was 
created there in the first place but Dmitry decided it should be solved 
in the core.
 From user's point of view this is very unfortunate: The only option I 
see is that realurl adds this in its own ext_localconf, overwriting TCA 
core definitions. Let us see what Dmitry thinks about this. If that 
doesn't work out this issue seems to be a won't fix and leads to yet 
another hack which is added to all of my customers production cores ...

Regards
Christian