[TYPO3-edu] nu stylez

[Mario Rimann]

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

Claudio Cathomen [ICSurselva AG] schrieb:
> Claudia Kessel has contributed 2 proposals for the future edu site:
> [snip]
> Discussion is open now, any ideas (and more styles) are welcome. As
> decided in august, we should choose our style until end of this month.
> Once we have decided that, production can start. Then we can still look
> how long it will take to us all, to finish texts, translations etc.

Hi Claudio

Thanks for providing us with the artwork! I liked both of them, but one
more than the other. Here's my feedback:

Layout 1:
- - I like the horizontal menu and the size of the content font.
- - Looks clear and is very close to typo3.com (what I think is positive).
- - The top-image is a bit bigger than on layout 2
- - The TYPO3 logo with ".edu" looks better if everything is on one line,
but I think it's to close to the TYPO3 Logo (see Styleguide)

Layout 2:
Looks good and impressed me on the first view. But after looking at both
the design sketches I found some points I don't like (in comparison to
layout 1):
- - the hat: it's very big, a good eye-catcher, but to big
- - the border around the whole content is to dark (looks like an
announcement of death in the newspaper)
- - the horizontal menu bar (font is not that readable as it could be)

I'd like to vote for Layout 1!

Cheers,
Mario

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.2.2 (GNU/Linux)
Comment: Using GnuPG with Mozilla - http://enigmail.mozdev.org

iD8DBQFFM+0o5yAXgAWej3wRAnVuAJ9AL17qFHbsG+AAcTD4P5mwhx0DzACgzqKf
OwFFiIecSCCvTNr7zmJU1bU=
=uD6L
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----