[TYPO3-dev] [TYPO3-core] [Poll] Integrate Speaking URLs in to TYPO3 CMS7

[Stefan Neufeind]

On 03/15/2015 05:21 PM, Benjamin Mack wrote:
> Hey everybody,
> 
> in the past years, there were (in my eyes) quite a majority of claiming
> that "Speaking URLs" in a enterprise manner should be part of the core.

[...]

> 1) Integrate RealURL as additional system extension, 

[...]

> 2) Come up with a full-fletched URL generating alternative for CMS7. I'm
> in favor of something like the ChainRouter of Symfony2 CMF Routing
> Framework (see http://symfony.com/doc/master/cmf/book/routing.html)

[...]


I agree with your view on having something "out of the box". And I
personally like RealURL, though I know many have a different view on that.

But I'm a bit unsure if we should go the way of shipping a sysext
(current RealURL possibly) and throw that over board for CMS 8 again
then. Dmitry afaik wanted to start from a clean base again, is that
right? Or would there be a migration-path towards RealURL 2 then?


Do you think it would be realistic to maybe try to join forces with the
planned development in the RealURL-universe and discuss with Dmitry if
your solution 2 (full-fletched solution) would be something he might
want to consider basing his work for a clean new "realurl" on?

If we integrate some full-featured and clean solution I don't see much
need for yet another newly developed solution in parallel (separate
RealURL 2). Maybe if there are parts that RealURL 2 wants to offer but
core decides it's going a bit too far then RealURL 2 could be an
extension to the core-mechanism?
Of course it's great to have alternatives - as with RealURL vs. CoolURI.
But multiplying the base-concepts "just because we can" doesn't seem
helpful to me imho.

Do you think that some routing-solution based on ChainRouter could be
integrated and "full-fletched" even for CMS7 then?
(I still need to take a look at ChainRouter.)


Kind regards,
 Stefan