[TYPO3-dev] Joomla - GPL bleibt GPL

[Martin Kutschker]

JoH asenau schrieb:
>>> If people are creating packages that are based on their own special
>>> TS setup and some HTML,CSS and images to give you a ready made and
>>> working TYPO3 site, they can use whatever license they like without
>>> ever violating the TYPO3 license because they don't use, extend or
>>> modify any of the TYPO3 libraries.
>> I agree, if the TS is not based and does not use any of the TS
>> extensions shipped with TYPO3 or available from TER and conatains no
>> PHP code that uses any TYPO3 functionality (pure standalone code).
> 
> Just to clarify this point:
> With TS extensions you mean stuff like CSS-styled-content?
> So if you import CSS-styled-content static template and then do
> 
> styles.content.get
> 
> this would be a no go, because CSS-styled-content as a whole is GPLed,
> while something like
> 
> 10 = CONTENT
> 10 {
>     table = tt_content
>     renderObj = CASE
>     renderObj {
>         blah
>     }
> }
> 
> would be OK, because this is just pure importable TS that is not depending
> on any GPLed extension.

Yes, this is what I meant.

> Which means, if the TS that is delivered in this
> case will just prepare a framework that will run with content(default),
> CSS-styled-content or any other proprietary TS setup or just a placeholer
> for different setups to create the content, this should be no problem too.
> 
> Agreed?

You mean you deliver saomething like that:

lib.myStuff.obj ...

And let the user copy the code into the right place in his template? I 
don't know if the user himself may ignore the fact that the different TS 
are distributed with different licences.

Masi