[TYPO3-ect] Extension Owner: "seo"

[Ronald Steiner]

Hi Benjamin,

just one critical remark to your extension.
Why do you want to include so many different things in only one extension?
I really love like some of the features in your extension, but in 
combination it puts me of from installing the extension. In my eyes 
these are completely different things:

1) separate field for title-tag per page
2) easy keywords and description editing
3) Google Sitemap (XML)
4) clean output in the HTML Header
5) Sitemap
...

I think about:
1) can be solved easily by pure TS - Just get the "subtitele" field 
shown in the <title> tag.
4) I use sourceoptimization for this task.

3+5)SiteMap and Google Sitemap are each cool features but in my eyes 
completely independent. They should be two independent extensions.

2) This is a really unique and very cool feature of your extension. I 
would love to use this one, but am put of by all the other features that 
I really don't need and want.

What do you think? I would love to hear about your reasons.

greetings

Ron



Benjamin Mack schrieb:
> Hey developers,
> 
> as some of you might know, I've been working on the "seo_basics" 
> extension in the last year. However, the feature that will come along in 
> the next months will go over the "basics", so I've been wondering about 
> the Extension Key "seo" which would suit way better as a defacto 
> standard for SEO management. Although there are no releases of this 
> extension on the TER yet, I found out the owner of the extension key 
> (thanks to the typo3.org team) and sent him emails about the key, to 
> multiple addresses and multiple times. But without a single answer.
> 
> So, I'd like to address this issue to the extension coordination team 
> what to do in this case. I would love to take over the extension and 
> make an awesome SEO extension that will be a good out-of-the-box 
> solution with some advanced features.
> 
> Could somebody help me what I should do in this case? thanks.
>