[TYPO3-ect] Extension Rating System and Reviews Status

[Patrick Rodacker]

Hi Elmar,

Elmar Hinz wrote on 22.07.2006 11:02:

> thank you for publishing your first draft of a concept. The schema already
> looks very detailed odered and clearn. I suggest to add another row that
> answers the question of motivation for each column.
> 
> For each column you should give an answer to the question: What motivates
> poeple to do this?
> 
> I give a maximum of 6 points for estimatied motivation (M).
> I give a maximum of 6 points for estimatied complexity (C).
> 
> Only if the motivation is as high as the complexity the concept can be
> successfull.
> 
> * Feature specifications (C:3)
> ** Developers want to make their extension successfull. (M:5) => works well
> 
> * T3 user rating: (C:1)
> ** Users want to express their annoyance or ecstasy (M:4) => works well
> 
> * T3 user reviews: (C:3)
> ** Users want to share their knowlage (M:3) => works partly
> *** Additional motivation should be given. Which?
> 
> * Security reviews: (C:5)
> ** Power to make extensions "officially supported": (M:3) => works hardly
> ** Money be the association: (M:6) => works well

Thinking about an estimation of the complexity and the motivation of the
different tasks is one of the next steps I will perform. Thanks for your
personal estimation so far, I will consider them and I will probably get
back to you all when discussing different tasks in detail.

Patrick