[TYPO3-ect] Extension Rating System and Reviews Status

[Elmar Hinz]

Hi Michael,

Michael Scharkow wrote:
>> That is Patricks part, who is our officail coordinator of the Ratings and
>> Revisions.
> 
> Sorry, just as you might feel offended but not being consulted on these
> issues, I don't like you calling any official coordinator of ratings and
> revisions. Who has appointed Patrick?
> 

Patrick is it within ECT whos newsgroup you are writing to. He has taken up
this role already in spring. You can read it in the official the wiki page.
I also have reported him as the coordinator of this project to the R&D
regularly.

http://wiki.typo3.org/index.php/Extension_coordination_team

> What about Robert, myself and lots  of volunteers who have worked in
> this area for a long time. The reviewing and ratings have been public in
> svn ever since, and the ratings were even publicly beta-tested.

Everybody has the opportunity to join the project group. You did not join
yet. Neither you signed in the wiki nor you answered in the mailing list to
join nor you asked me in private. Patrick actively tried several times to
get in contact with you about this matters. So maybe it is a good idea to
join now.

> 
> I very much support Patrick taking over these issues, but helping is
> about getting work done, not about official titles.
> 

Both is necassary. But I agree that the output is what counts in the end.
The work of a coordinatior includes the work of coordination and
communication. For coordination it is necassary to have a name and a
person, where people can address to.




Regards

Elmar