[TYPO3-core] RFC #11119: DBAL: Mapping in query does not takes care of remapping "table.field" in a WHERE clause

[Mathias Schreiber [wmdb >]]

Ingo Renner schrieb:
> Martin Kutschker wrote:
> 
> Hi Masi,
> 
>>> without a core team member's +1 on reading and testing?
>>
>> As DBAL patches will never get tested I do at least read the stuff.
> 
> well, then we should do something about it, see my other posts today 
> about VMs. However, simply committing stuff without testing renders the 
> review process null and void.

In regards of DBAL it mainly blocks the development.
As in my other post I already suggested to exclude DBAL (at least 
oracle) from reviewing, since there is a lot more to administering 
databases than downloading an appliance and pressing "play".

Most core-devs are pretty busy doing other stuff (and this is a good 
thing) and Xavier is practically the only one active in DBAL.

So either his patches get commited and the few working with DBAL can fix 
stuff or nothing gets tested and DBAL get's stuck in place.

Generally I am very "in" for the review process but I think it is not 
really applicable in this special situation.

Plus I think it should be stated that this is a very special occassion 
and that it is very unlikely to exclude other "parts" of the core from 
being tripple-checked by the "classic" workflow.

I just feel sorry for Xavier, whose "Reminder #12" keep echoing through 
this list.

cheers
Mathias


-- 
TYPO3 certified interogator
T3DD09 Entertainer