[TYPO3-english] Fluidtemplate and TemplaVoila

[Thomas Skierlo]

Hi Tolleiv

> Hi,
>
> that's only partly possible - the TemplaVoila page module depends on 
> existing page templates so you'd have to provide those to use the page 
> module and to maintain the FCEs. The frontend-rendering of FCEs could 
> work standalone.


I know what you mean. I could live with the two page modules, but could 
the editors too?


>
> Is Fluid really justifying that double work?

No, not really. The only part of all new technologies I tried with kind 
of success was Fluidtemplate for the page template. In combination with 
BE Layout (the one from core) it even might be more intuitive than the 
TV mappings. When it comes to FCE all this (not so) new stuff like 
Extbase, gridelements a.s.o. is rather disillusioning. You know and I 
know that there might be a TV for 6.x, but there will never be any for 
Neos. All people like me who want to be prepared for the day to come are 
forced back on the ground after month of struggling without success.

It's good to know that many good things from Neos will be back-ported to 
TYPO3. Why not replace all that (in my very personal opinion) useless 
Extbase-stuff by a decent way of handling "multiple content" and 
"sections". This must not necessarily be the TV way, at least if there 
is any other (better) way, preferrably with static file usage. Without 
core based multicontent handling you are either 100% dependant on TV, or 
you loose FCE functionallity, or versioning, or localization, or your 
"market" - or all of your nerves.

Keep up your good work!

Cheers,

Thomas


>
> Cherrs.
>
>
> Thomas Skierlo schrieb:
>> Hello,
>>
>> since I did not succeed in replacing TemplaVoila FCE by new technologies
>> my last idea is to use it only for FCE. Does anybody know if it is
>> possible to use Fluidtemplate for the page template together with TV for
>> FCE?
>>
>> Regards,
>>
>> Thomas
>>
>