[TYPO3-english] Realurl and pages with same path/title

[Ernesto Baschny [cron IT]]

Dmitry Dulepov wrote: on 22.10.2008 13:24:

> Ernesto Baschny [cron IT] wrote:
>> Maybe it is there to provide access to pages UNDER the hidden page,
>> those should get the page-path from the hidden page. E.g.:
>>
>> A
>>  |-- B (hidden)
>>  |   `-- C
>>  |-- B (visible)
>>      `-- D
>>
>> The path to "C" will be a/b/c (where "B" is the hidden "B").
> 
> May be. I truly do not remember :(
> 
>> Nevertheless it is clearly a bug to print have "a/b" return a "non
>> accessible page". If we humans can distinguish it, TYPO3 / RealURL
>> should also be able to do so. :) It might be technically "difficult" or
>> doesn't fit in the current concept, but nevertheless is clearly a bug
>> (as I have once submitted http://bugs.typo3.org/view.php?id=7547).

> RealURL does not print these things :) TYPO3 does. RealURL gets
> string and returns integer. That's all. Who will do what with that
> integer — RealURL neither knows, nor cares :)

Yes, but RealURL is a TYPO3 extension, and it should know and also be
able to handle TYPO3-related stuff (language-settings, enable-fields,
and even user-groups).

> I still acknowledge the problem. It *is* a problem. But solution
> needs thinking. Jumping to fix it quickly will be wrong because it
> may break something else.

Of course. I trust that if you find the solution, it will be a good and
complete one! :)

Cheers,
Ernesto