[TYPO3-dev] List of modifications for TemplaVoila

[Stig Nørgaard Færch]

R. van Twisk skrev:
> JoH asenau wrote:
>>>>> Unfortunately I do not see Tapio's e-mails for a year or so, so I
>>>>> could not read his mails anyway.
>>>>>
>>>>>         
>>>> It seems that is fruiless to do that - I would like to show
>>>> something a larger collection of changes, but because of this
>>>> attitude, I believe that it is fruitless. Anyway I get more money,
>>>> if I do customer-specific versions.
>>>>       
>>> Tapio,
>>>
>>> If that is the case why do you at all bother to post your
>>> modifications on the list? I am trying to understand this. Why is it
>>> so hard to contact a developer or post patches on the bugtracker?
>>>     
>>
>> Well - in this case it's hard to contact the responsible developer, 
>> because
>> Dmitry (like many others) decided to ignore Tapio's mails. And I can
>> understand that it is not very comfortable to split the whole stuff up 
>> into
>> smaller chunks and file a feature request for each of them in the
>> bugtracker.
>>
>>  
>>> What is your motivation to call this fruitless? Your ideas do not
>>> seem to bad if I look at them.
>>>     
>>
>> It seems that Tapio's behaviour now is paying back. Many people told him
>> that it's not wise to talk about the work of other people in the way 
>> he did.
>> Now he has got the problem, that his work, even though it might not be 
>> too
>> bad, is more ore less ignored by those people.
>>
>> Bad luck ...
>>
>> But maybe both, Tapio and Dmitry could take a step back and try to start
>> again with a more professional behaviour ;-)
>>
>> Would be good for the project ...
>>
>> Joey
>>
>>   
> 
> hey Guys,
> 
> I just wanted to tell that Tapio did a great job on my project. He did 
> meet the deadline
> and he also did meet the requirements where it was possible to meet the 
> requirements.
> IF there was no good 'TYPO3' solution, then Tapio could always find a 
> suitable solution
> that could meet my clients requirements.
> 
> Great job Tapio!!!!
> 
> Currently we are waiting for clients approval and bug solving phase but 
> it looks good.
> 
> Now this, Tapio want's to give the changes back to the community which 
> is great!
> I also don't understand Dmitrys behaviors, it seems like he wants to 
> have all
> changes nicely spread and documented on bugtrack like morning breakfast 
> in a hotel.
> That is not an open source spirit!

Well, I understand why using the bugtracker is preferable. If everyone 
had their own different way of supplying with new patch, feature 
requests and so on, the developer could soon lose the overview. Keeping 
things like this in a system is a must.
I haven't used the bugtracker much, but is it that hard following these 
guidelines?

> Dmitry could also ask for the patch and do a diff and see what changes 
> are in there,
> for sure we could (Tapio and me) write down what we changed and do
> some code documentation on it and everybody is happy. Communication is
> the key!! (see typo's slogan on typo3.com)

And then putting it on the bugtracker? Isn't that the common guideline?

/Stig