[TYPO3-ect] 8 valid votings - snapshot 4 - Update

Jan-Hendrik Heuing [DD] jh at digitaldistrict.de
Thu Jan 5 22:19:00 CET 2006


>  Distribute 5 votes for "Alltimestars" (max. 3 votes per extension):
>
>  [1] chc_forum: CHC Forum proposed by Michelle Heizer
>  [2] cron_cssstyledimgtext: CSS styled IMGTEXT proposed by Hauke Haller
>  [2] rtehtmlarea: htmlArea RTE proposed by by Ernesto Bashny

This is mostly personal... Either they use a lot of external code or are 
rather small solutions, so I do not see the beauty of a nice extension in 
terms of concept, codebase etc, the overall picture...

>  Distribute 5 votes for "Newcomers" (max. 3 votes per extension):
>
>  [0] dam: Media (DAM) proposed by by Stefan Geith
>  [2] timtab: TIMTAB Weblog proposed by Thomas Hempel
>  [3] timtaw: TimTaw proposed by Frank Holzinger

This is much more difficult.

Timtaw itself seems not to be a big deal, the more interesting part of it is 
be_acl, which is mendatory. So it's getting points for being major reason of 
developing be_acl ;) Of course the combination of both shows the power.

Timtab has grown a lot since I first looked at it, so it also deservers some 
points!

But I guess the real winner is DAM. Problem here: It is not really a 
newcomer, it is under development for ages ;) And following development, I 
can only say good things about it, hijacking plugin-code is part of the 
story :D

As DAM is winning here anyway, I just leave it out and vote for either 
timtab or timtaw which I favour more. I guess this is also fair if we 
consider that the newcomer is actualy one of those sleepers ;)

Hope I get not kicked out for changing the rules for my voting ;)

Jan-Hendrik





More information about the TYPO3-team-extension-coordination mailing list