[TYPO3-core] RFC: Cosmetic Change Sitemap to Special Menus #7093

[Steffen Kamper]

Hi Dmitry,

"Dmitry Dulepov [typo3]" <dmitry at typo3.org> schrieb im Newsbeitrag 
news:mailman.1.1199689104.11336.typo3-team-core at lists.netfielders.de...
> Hi, Steffen!
>
> Steffen Kamper wrote:
>> Type: Cosmetic Change
>
> No such type. Value must be in_array('Bugfix', 'New feature', 'Code 
> cleanup'), see http://typo3.org/teams/core/core-mailinglist-rules/

ok, but i didn't found any is matching right, may be Code cleanup.

>
>> change wording to "Special Menus", change default value from wizard to 
>> "Menu
>> of these pages"
>
> In general I am neutral to the idea, mainly because it will be very 
> unclear to old existing TYPO3 users to undersrtand where their favorite 
> Sitemaps disappeared and what are these special menus. But this is not a 
> reason to block HCI team changes because they make lots of sence.
>
hav e a look to the screenshot - you see wording Sitemap as well, so it will 
be easy to find.

> Unfortunately pure technical -1 to the patch for now because it breaks 
> language packs for previous TYPO3 versions. Existing labels may not be 
> altered or deleted.
>
> Corresponding block in the patch:
>
>> - <label index="CType.I.12">Menu/Sitemap</label>
>> + <label index="CType.I.12">Special Menus</label>

you are right, this is the reason why i used new labels. In this case i 
altered because the label name is kind of array corresponding to the CType, 
so i don't saw an alternative here.
>
> You have to introduce and use another label but keep existing ones for 
> compatibility with 3.x, 4.0.x and 4.1.x branches. Remember: language packs 
> are shared for all TYPO3 versions! So if you change CType.I.12, people 
> will have "Sitemap" in English but "Special menus" in translated versions! 
> You need to add CType.I.12.A or something similar (may be even 
> CType.I.12.Special_menus).
>

ok, i changed it with new attached patch.
But what happens with now unneeded labels? Should they 
stay/uncommented/deleted? i choose first one in this patch.

vg  Steffen 


begin 666 20080106_specialmenus.2.diff
M26YD97 at Z('1Y<&\S+W-Y<V5X="]C;7,O;&%Y;W5T+V1B7VYE=U]C;VYT96YT
M7V5L+G!H< T*/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]
M/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/0T*+2TM('1Y<&\S+W-Y
M<V5X="]C;7,O;&%Y;W5T+V1B7VYE=U]C;VYT96YT7V5L+G!H< DH<F5V:7-I
M;VX@,C at V."D-"BLK*R!T>7!O,R]S>7-E>'0O8VUS+VQA>6]U="]D8E]N97=?
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M='EP92<@/3X@, at HK"0D)"0DG;65N=5]T>7!E)R ]/B P"B )"0D)*0H@"0D)
M*2P*( D)"2=S<&5C:6%L7W!L86EN2%1-3"<@/3X at 87)R87DH"2\O(%!L86EN
M($A434P*26YD97 at Z('1Y<&\S+W-Y<V5X="]C;7,O;&%Y;W5T+VQO8V%L;&%N
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M/DEN<V5R=', at 82!M961I82!E;&5M96YT(&QI:V4 at 82!&;&%S:"!A;FEM871I
M;VXL(&%U9&EO(&9I;&4@;W(@=FED96\@8VQI<"X\+VQA8F5L/@H@"0D)/&QA
M8F5L(&EN9&5X/2)S<&5C:6%L7W-I=&5M87!?=&ET;&4B/E-I=&5M87 \+VQA
M8F5L/@H@"0D)/&QA8F5L(&EN9&5X/2)S<&5C:6%L7W-I=&5M87!?9&5S8W)I
M<'1I;VXB/D-R96%T97, at 82!S:71E;6%P(&]F('1H92!W96)S:71E+CPO;&%B
M96P^"BL)"0D\;&%B96P@:6YD97@](G-P96-I86Q?;65N=7-?=&ET;&4B/E-P
M96-I86P at 365N=7,\+VQA8F5L/@HK"0D)/&QA8F5L(&EN9&5X/2)S<&5C:6%L
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M86)E;"!I;F1E>#TB9F]R;7,B/D9O<FT at 96QE;65N=',\+VQA8F5L/@I 0" M
M-# L-" K-#(L-"! 0 T*( D)"3QL86)E;"!I;F1E>#TB<&QU9VEN<U]G96YE
M<F%L7V1E<V-R:7!T:6]N(CY396QE8W0@=&AI<R!E;&5M96YT('1Y<&4@=&\@
M:6YS97)T(&$@<&QU9VEN('=H:6-H(&-A;FYO="!B92!F;W5N9"!A;6]N9W-T
M('1H92!O<'1I;VYS(&)E;&]W+CPO;&%B96P^"B )"3PO;&%N9W5A9V5+97D^
M"B )/"]D871A/@HM/"]4,VQO8V%L;&%N9SX-"EP at 3F\@;F5W;&EN92!A="!E
M;F0@;V8 at 9FEL90T**SPO5#-L;V-A;&QA;F<^"DEN9&5X.B!T>7!O,R]S>7-E
M>'0O8VUS+VQO8V%L;&%N9U]T=&,N>&UL#0H]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]
M/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]
M/3T]#0HM+2T@='EP;S,O<WES97AT+V-M<R]L;V-A;&QA;F=?='1C+GAM; DH
M<F5V:7-I;VX@,C at V."D-"BLK*R!T>7!O,R]S>7-E>'0O8VUS+VQO8V%L;&%N
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M97 at Z('1Y<&\S+W-Y<V5X="]C;7,O=&)L7W1T7V-O;G1E;G0N<&AP#0H]/3T]
M/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]
M/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]/3T]#0HM+2T@='EP;S,O<WES97AT+V-M<R]T8FQ?
M='1?8V]N=&5N="YP:' )*')E=FES:6]N(#(X-C at I#0HK*RL@='EP;S,O<WES
M97AT+V-M<R]T8FQ?='1?8V]N=&5N="YP:' )*'=O<FMI;F<@8V]P>2D-"D! 
M("TV,RPW("LV,RPW($! #0H@"0D)"0EA<G)A>2 at G3$Q,.D585#IC;7,O;&]C
M86QL86YG7W1T8RYX;6PZ0U1Y<&4N9&EV+G-P96-I86PG+" G+2UD:78M+2<I
M+ H@"0D)"0EA<G)A>2 at G3$Q,.D585#IC;7,O;&]C86QL86YG7W1T8RYX;6PZ
M0U1Y<&4N22XW)RP@)VUU;'1I;65D:6$G+" G:2]T=%]C;VYT96YT7VUM+F=I
M9B<I+ H@"0D)"0EA<G)A>2 at G3$Q,.D585#IC;7,O;&]C86QL86YG7W1T8RYX
M;6PZ0U1Y<&4N22XQ,2<L("=S<&QA<V at G+" G:2]T=%]C;VYT96YT7VYE=W,N
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M:2]T=%]C;VYT96YT7W-H;W)T8W5T+F=I9B<I+ H@"0D)"0EA<G)A>2 at G3$Q,
M.D585#IC;7,O;&]C86QL86YG7W1T8RYX;6PZ0U1Y<&4N22XQ-"<L("=L:7-T
M)RP@)VDO='1?8V]N=&5N=%]L:7-T+F=I9B<I+ H@"0D)"0EA<G)A>2 at G3$Q,
M.D585#IC;7,O;&]C86QL86YG7W1T8RYX;6PZ0U1Y<&4N22XQ-2<L("=S8W)I
A<'0G+" G:2]T=%]C;VYT96YT7W-C<FEP="YG:68G*2P*
`
end