[TYPO3] newloginbox TYPO3 core integration

[Johnny Peck]

Darko Jr. Gonzalez wrote:
> Heya
> 
> I just saw the upload comment of "feuserlisting" here: 
> http://typo3.org/extensions/repository/view/feuserlisting/0.9.0/
> 
> Why newloginbox goes into core TYPO3 instead of sr_feuser_register? Just 
> wondering really, because sr_feuser_register offers more and it is more 
> feature-rich. Pretty much (de-facto) standardized process on many web 
> frameworks works like that.
> 
> 
> Cheers,
> Darko

Darko,

	Both are very nice extensions but they serve different purposes.  I 
have not read that newloginbox is going to the core but I doubt the 
entire extension is being placed there.  Keeping a lean and feature rich 
core is important to TYPO3 (at least that is the hope ;) ) and 
sr_feuser_register does not provide functionality that is required by 
all implementations of T3 thus it should stay as an extension. 
Newloginbox, on the other hand, can be important for editors of a 
website and not just users of a website.

Just my 2 cents.  Anyone have more about this?

Aloha