[TYPO3-dev] RFC: public extension review process

[Elmar Hinz]

Elmar Hinz wrote:

> Hello together,
> 
> the list of the core team has been opened, introducing a defined
> proceeding for patch reviewing at the same time. I have the impression,
> that this measurement was successful. From my subjectiv feelings the PPP
> quote (patches per period) did increase noticeable. Is that measurable?
> 
> There is another field in the community workflow that doesn't work in
> practice - the extension reviews. How about a similar approach to get the
> extensions reviewed? Could that improve the current situation?
> 
> Regards
> 
> Elmar


Hello all,

a request for comments without comments! Great. Can we conclude from this,
that there is no interest in reviewed extensions any more? Well certainly
for reviewed extensions, but no interest to maintain such a system, that
regularly requires a lot of work to be done.

Then we should seriously consider to remove that system from the extension
manager. Shoudn't we. I find it confusing an not helpful in any way.

I also doesn't give a good picture, if such a system is shipped, but not
maintained. I have doubt, that it is of any use for the community as is.

Regards

Elmar