[Typo3-dev] "Clean up" in the extension repository?

[Mathias Schreiber [K1net]]

Stig N. Jepsen wrote:
> Just an idea.
> Wouldn't it be nice if extensions were reviewed by an 'Quality review
> team'? I'm not thinking as much about the usage of the extension but
> more code-wise.
> That is if the code of the exension lives up to certain coding rules.

?
This is happening already.
Ever seen the little "being reviewed" icons on typo3.org? :)

> If a developer asks for a quality review for his extension, he should
> get comments about his work and then get a  "Typo3 Approved"-stamp or
> something like that if the extension lives up to the standards. Or
> maybe a star-points system.

it's cigars rather than stars.

> The quality of the extension should of course be very visible in the
> extension manager.

This idea is new. Sounds reasonable.
We discussed this back in summer but 3.6 got priority.

> Or how about a reviewsystem or pollsystem???

No poll please.
Folks will vote up their extensions.